The pot and the kettle

KFOX TV aired a segment the other day that gives us a pretty clear idea where we are at EPISD.

According to the current president of the non-elected board of managers:

“We didn’t have time to peel back the onion and get in there and look at the numbers like we’ve been doing for the last several months, and they spent more than $73,000 protesting us,” Margo said. “I frankly think if they were honorable people, they’d reimburse the district because that looked like they did it for their own egos.”

Honorable?  Egos?

Then again maybe it takes one to know one.

Quoting further from the KFOX segment:

In response to Margo’s statements, Castanon-Williams sent KFOX14 the following statement:

“The Board of Managers, under Mr. Margo’s leadership, has been in place for over a year. They need to take responsibility for their gross mismanagement of this school district.  This unelected Board of Managers has completely squandered and mishandled the district’s money from day one: 1) They hired a superintendent at an insane salary of $285,000 a year–which is a salary that is more than the salary of our Vice President of the United States, Joseph Biden, who earns $230,700 a year. In fact, Superintendent Cabrera’s salary exceeds the salaries of every U.S. representative and senator in Washington, D.C., including every member of the White House staff.  This salary is not one that this school district can afford.

2) They eliminated more than 130 teaching positions for alleged budgetary shortfalls; but hired several expensive administrators to help the new superintendent at central office and across the district, while he learns how to do his job on the job, because he has never been a superintendent before.

3)  They unethically reallocated to the Westside a substantial part of the $54 million of the 2007 bond money that was promised to Northeast El Paso for a new high school, so that they could build a new football stadium on the Westside at Franklin High School this year.  As a result, the substantial needs of the schools in Northeast El Paso have been minimized and will go unmet.

Furthermore, there is no legal authority for this Managing Board to remain in place after an election took place in May 2013 following their appointment.  In short, their continued presence in place of a newly elected board of trustees may well be illegal.

Under the elected Williams, Dodge, & Hughes Board, in spite of huge state budget cuts that Mr. Margo voted for as State Representative, the district had a balanced budget every year, saved money out of each budget which was put into the fund balance (savings account) for emergencies resulting in $87 million that the Board of Managers inherited from the elected school board of trustees. We received the prestigious Texas Comptroller Leadership Circle Gold Member award for outstanding fiscal management three years in a row, we kept all teachers on the job, and gave all employees substantial salary increases they well deserved.

As the elected board members, we continue to support the right of the people to have their elected leaders represent them, especially given the disastrous performance of the Board of Managers that is not elected so it does not represent the people of this community.  One Managing Board member, Dr. Castleberry, has never lived in El Paso and may be flying into El Paso at the school district’s expense for board and workshop meetings.  Who is paying for her flight and hotel expenses? Another Managing Board member, Dr. Blanca Enriquez, does not live in the school district at all. This Board of Managers was appointed by and is accountable only to a Commissioner in Austin with his own agenda.”

Margo sent KFOX14 his own statement in response.

“Cabrera’s  compensation package is less than Garcia’s.  Garcia had a base salary of $280,314 plus business expenses, a $2,000 per month car allowance, $1,000 for telephone and internet, liberal vacation, a $1 million life insurance policy, pension contributions, separate annuity, and a performance bonus on district test scores that I’m told equated to an additional $54,000 his last year, Cabrera does not have this,” Margo said.

“Teaching positions were reduced through attrition and retirements.  There have been no layoffs.  The district is merely matching the correct ratio of teachers to students as prior year budgets overestimated incorrectly ADA (average daily attendance) which determines our state revenues to district.  It was a case of poor oversight by prior trustees. 2010-11, 2011-12, 2012-13, and 2014-15 have a projected drop in enrollment of 3,377 costing somewhere in excess of $18 million to EPISD,” he said.

“Bond funds were repurposed for classroom additions and other related projects after several public meetings conducted by the Bond Oversight Committee and their approval. The Committee was presented with demographic data that showed a new northeast high school would not be needed for several years and we had more pressing immediate needs for classrooms and other facilities at existing schools.  Prior budgets approved by Trustees failed to acknowledge that the average age of EPISD’s 94 campuses is approximately 56 years and maintenance costs are higher and escalating as a result.  No analysis has been conducted on the physical condition of schools or the population demographic changes since 2000!  We’re using some of the repurposed bond funds for such a study to be presented on June 17.

For the most part we have protected our Fund Balance Reserves, but the decision made by Dodge, Castenon-Williams and Hughes in July of 2010, to leave EPISD’s self-funded health insurance program and join TRS (contrary to HR committee recommendations and their ins consultant recs) will cost the district a minimum of $10 million this next fiscal year and cost us an additional $6 million already this fiscal year.

They have no excuses–they have failed to do anything other than protect their own egos–the children and taxpayers have not mattered.”

We deserve better

Brutus

8 Responses to The pot and the kettle

  1. Jerry Kurtyka's avatar Jerry Kurtyka says:

    I tend to agree with Margo. Until the previous elected board members responsible for the Garcia fiasco cycle out of office or resign, I would not dismiss the current board of managers however much I dislike their policies. It is just out of the frying pan and into the fire. El Paso can’t seem to get anything right it is so corrupted by vested interests and criminals in office.

    So, the State has an obligation to enforce this and keep the current board in power. Unless, of course, they (board of managers) proceed to loot the district or egregiously transfer assets to private parties like their friends at the City have done. Then, we need a revolution!

    Like

  2. LT's avatar LT says:

    Its time for a federal lawsuit to be filed. Garcia is gone and so are his cohorts so there no reason for the board of managers to continue. Its time for the elected officials to take the office they were elected too.

    Like

    • Jerry Kurtyka's avatar Jerry Kurtyka says:

      Wrong. The EPISD elected board members most responsible for the Garcia mess are still in office, though dis-empowered. People like Dodge won’t resign but choose to serve out their term, thus ensuring the continuation of the board of managers. Their egos are more important to them than the well-being of EPISD.

      Would you want those incompetents to be reinstated? Not me.

      Like

  3. Dan Bodine's avatar Dan Bodine says:

    Is is not an ideal time for the ISD to take over the Lincoln Center building from the state for $1 to use as new admin center? Save a lot of money and do something special for the city, too! What am I as a newcomer missing here? (http://desertmountaintimes.com/2014/06/lincoln-as-el-paso-isd-central-office-could-be-love-fest/#more-1997) Logistics don’t match? Scenery doesn’t match?

    Like

    • Unknown's avatar Jerry K says:

      What you are missing is that the PTP would like to move EPISD downtown where our taxes would pay rent to an investor.

      Like

      • Dan Bodine's avatar Dan Bodine says:

        Apologize for the late reply on this, Jerry. My idea was both simply one of those “common sense” suggestions and, also, something so charged with potential it seemed too tantalizing not to run it.

        Not being an “insider” here, the PTP wanting to subsidize investors thru rent payments seems far-fetched. Just first sniff. Thanks immensely for the comment though, and again my apologies for not watching the boxes better.

        Like

        • Unknown's avatar Reality Checker says:

          If you think Jerry’s concern is far-fetched, look no farther than the scheme crafted by city council, management and certain special interest groups to cut taxpayers out of a decision to subsidize a for-profit sports team for the benefit of its owners and other downtown property investors. Subsidies come in a lot of different forms, shapes and sizes.

          Like

  4. Unknown's avatar grandparent says:

    The mess EPISD is in is a direct result of people like Williams and Dodge. They were asleep at the wheel while the administrators and principals were cheating on tests and while they accepted inflated enrollment numbers resulting in today’s financial mess. They allowed certain administrators, principals and teachers to run the school through a culture of corruption. I hope the Board of Managers stays in place until Williams and Dodge cycle off. Even then, it is doubtful we can elect intelligent, responsible board members. Worst school board ever! And, yes, they should pay for the legal bills they incurred.

    Like

Leave a reply to Reality Checker Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.